By KiddieDaily Editors · 2026-06-29 · 3 min read · 1 source

Hold the onions – and see if they make you cry

📊 Source Analysis — KiddieDaily Editorial
Left
Right Center
🧪 New Scientist
11% source agreement Covered by 1 independent source

Bias ratings based on AllSides + Ad Fontes Media. Agreement % = sources covering this story. Always read multiple sources and think critically.

Feedback is New Scientist’s popular sideways look at the latest science and technology news.

You can submit items you believe may amuse readers to Feedback by emailing feedback@newscientist.com Feedback could never be a professional chef. That’s partly because there is no way we could stand the pressure of such a frantic work environment, to say nothing of the stress of potentially running into Gordon Ramsay. But mostly it’s because we would tear up every time we had to chop an onion.

The reason some of us cry when we chop onions is a chemical called syn-propanethial-S-oxide, which gets sprayed into the air. It triggers the trigeminal nerve, which, in turn, activates the tear ducts to wash away the irritating chemical. So far, so annoying, but also so understudied.

Is everyone equally sensitive to onions, or do we vary? And are people who are more sensitive to onion chemicals also more sensitive to chemicals generally – for instance, do they have a stronger sense of smell? “No research to date has explored subjective individual variability in onion tearing and its relationship to chemosensory sensitivity,” write Thomas Hummel and his colleagues in a “preliminary investigation” published on 25 May in the journal – and, fair warning, this is an absolute mouthful, so good luck to whoever’s doing the audio version of this column – Laryngoscope Investigative Otolaryngology.

Hummel’s team recruited 1001 volunteers and asked them to rate their sense of smell, the general state of their nasal passages, their sensitivity to stinging and burning sensations, and their propensity for crying over onions. The participants were also given psychophysical tests: for instance, they were given sticks imbued with odours and had to identify them. It turned out that the people who self-reported more tearing while cutting onions also self-reported having a better sense of smell.

However, the psychophysical tests didn’t bear this out. The people who said they were prone to crying over onions didn’t do any better on the sniff tests than those who said onions didn’t bother them. Feedback has stared at these results for a day and we think what they are telling us is that people are bad at assessing their own sense of smell.

As the authors put it: “These findings are consistent with previous research demonstrating low correlations between subjective olfactory ability ratings and psychophysical olfactory tests.” We suspect this is in the same category as people’s tendency to believe they are above-average at driving, telling jokes and interpreting complicated scientific data. Happily, Feedback doesn’t suffer from this delusion. We know our sense of smell is bad, because Mrs Feedback detected the iffy scent in the living room well before we did, which is why it took us so long to find the dead mouse one of Feedback’s felines had so graciously hidden behind the sideboard.

Think About This

What questions does this story raise for you? Talk with your family: Why does this news matter? Who is affected? What might happen next? Is there anything you can do?

🔬 Parent discussion guide

KiddieDaily is built for families — balanced sources, no agenda, no ads. Always read the original source and think for yourself.

Original Sources

🔍 Want to verify this story? Check it on Google Fact Check Explorer →

📰
Get today's digest All of today's kid-safe stories in one parent-friendly roundup — with bias ratings.
Read digest →

More stories: Kid News · Archive · Fact Check

← All news RSS feed